Best and worst Porsche Boxster years — which to avoid

The Porsche Boxster is a convenient way to get into the Porsche family without paying the full price for a 911. However, it had a fair share of reliability issues related to certain model years, which is why you need to be aware of the Porsche Boxster years to avoid before making the final decision.

Well, in this guide we’ll address the main issues by providing you with all the necessary details on Porsche Boxster’s recalls, complaints, and driver opinions on frequent problems that could make or break your driving experience.

Why you can trust REREV’s advice on which car model years to avoid: Our car experts look at official data, ask real drivers what they think, and talk to experienced mechanics to make sure our list is useful. This reliable info can make buying a car easier for you. Want to know how we do it? Find out more about our research methodology.

How we rated the best and worst Porsche Boxster years

To properly rate the best and worst Porsche Boxster years, our team first needed to obtain proven and verified information on the model’s reliability. So, we did some digging and found out a lot by going through NHTSA files and submissions regarding common complaints and recalls.

We also wanted to hear what owners had to say about the car, so we scrolled through the forums, as well as Boxster reviews on Edmunds, KBB, and Consumer Reports for more details on specific model years. By comparing and double-checking all these, we’ve created the following list of the best and worst Boxster years:

Most common Porsche Boxster problems

While the Boxster surely isn’t as good as the 911, many drivers are unaware that it shares a lot of engine construction aspects with its larger counterpart. While that’s usually a good thing, the downside of it is that the Boxster also struggles with the intermediate shaft bearing which degrades over time.

This issue, as well as a few other common problems of the Boxster, have made drivers look the other way when it comes to buying the affected model years, so here’s a brief explanation of each problem.

1. Problems with the intermediate shaft bearing

This was the common issue for Porsche cars back in the early 2000s, and it mostly caught up with the 996 and the first-gen Boxster. The early models of second-gen Boxster were also impacted by this fault and it’s a serious problem that sometimes required owners to completely replace or rebuild the engine.

It’s a bearing that helped synchronize the rotation of the camshafts and the crankshaft independently from each other. It’s a vital purpose for the engine and in theory, it should preserve the engine and make it last a while longer. However, it turned out to be one of the worst engineering decisions by Porsche since the bearing was prone to failure every 50,000 miles or so and required expensive repairs.

If you are going for an early Boxster model. at least make sure to get a 2007 or later one where the IMS issue has been sorted out. On the other hand, you can do what’s up to you and have a trusted mechanic with knowledge of Porsche parts examine the bearing beneath the crankshaft to see if it needs a replacement.

2. Engine oil leaks

Another common problem of the Boxster is the engine oil leak, and this is dangerous since oil lubricates metal components within the engine. So, it prolongs the life span of the pistons and other components by reducing friction damage. While it’s also crucial to know what oil the car takes and refill regularly, it’s also worth inspecting the rear oil cooler seals and leaks from the oil separator.

The separator is also important since it redistributes oil back into the engine and a leak could cause smoke to come from the exhaust. In the worst-case scenario, oil leaks could lead to overheating engine, so it’s worth checking if the separators have ever been repaired before. Drivers have reported that these are prone to failure even before the car reaches the mileage of 100,000 on the clock.

3. Airbag problems

The airbag problems specific to the Boxster model even triggered an official recall by Porsche and there were two common issues here. First, there’s a reported case of the SRS light glowing up on the dashboard for no obvious reason, and this one was usually caused by poor electric connections.

However, an even more serious issue is with the malfunction of the engine control unit (ECU) that collects data from various sensors and controls different car systems. It also operates the airbag control module, and there was a known defect of the ECU that caused a malfunction of the control module. So, it could lead to inoperable airbags that posed safety threats and Porsche initiated a recall in 2019 to fix this.

4. Problems with car components

Finally, this issue may not be as serious as some other issues we’ve inspected so far, but it’s still worth checking into. Namely, the Boxster suffers from various faulty components like malfunctioning seatbelts that may cause them to loosen up while driving.

On top of that, we’ve found a fair share of driver complaints about a faulty hood latch. The latch issue sometimes caused the hood to rise in the middle of a drive, causing visibility and safety issues. Thankfully, Porsche issued an official recall in 2014 to fix the faulty hood latch. We’ve also seen numerous reports regarding the leaking sunroof.

Worst Porsche Boxster years to avoid

The most important thing when buying a used Porsche Boxster is to know about certain model years that have proved to be less reliable than others. Most of these affect the first and second generation of the Boxster, so what are the worst Porsche Boxster years?

The worst Porsche Boxster years are 2003 and 2005, but it may be a good idea to stay away from any of these:

• 1997
• 1999
• 2002
• 2003
• 2005
• 2010
• 2015
• 2016

We’ll give you a helping hand by further explaining these model years and mentioning which issues they were affected with to save you the trouble of going for a bad model.

First-generation Boxster (1997-1999 and 2002-2003 model years)

The first generation of the Boxster was arguably one of the most problematic generations and there are several model years to avoid here. You should steer away from the initial 1997 Boxster up to the 1999 model year, and while a few reliable model years follow up, the 2002-2003 model also received a lot of complaints.

Some of the most common problems here include the issue of the intermediate shaft bearing as well as electric problems and there were even some problems with the transmission for the 1999 model year.

Second-generation Boxster (2005 and 2010 model years)

When it comes to the second-gen Boxster, two model years stand out as the worst in this generation – the 2005 model and the 2010 model. These were some of the worst model years along with 2003 when it comes to the number of driver complaints.

Most of the complaints were associated with electrical problems and the problem of oil leaks was still present. It’s also wise to avoid the 2005 and 2006 model years for their consistent issues with the intermediate shaft bearing and go for a 2009 or 2011 model.

Third-generation Boxster (2015-2016 model years)

The third generation of Boxster was in production from 2012 to 2016 and there weren’t many reported issues for this generation. The intermediate shaft bearing problem was long gone by that time, and drivers have only complained about the airbag module faults and faulty hood latches.

These issues were settled with a later recall for the 2015 to 2016 models and that’s why it’s perhaps wise to avoid these model years. However, all the other model years from 2012 to 2014 are more or less hassle-free for drivers in terms of urgent servicing needs.

What are the best Porsche Boxster years to buy?

Porsche Boxster had some pretty reliable model years and that’s why we wanted to introduce you both to reliable models, and some less reliable ones. Now, after going through the problems of bothersome model years, we can happily recommend you the best production years:

• 1998
• 2000
• 2001
• 2004
• 2006
• 2007
• 2008
• 2009
• 2011
• 2012
• 2013
• 2014
• 2017
• 2018
• 2019
• 2020
• 2021

Except for the model years troubled with the IMS failure, the first and second-gen Boxster was pretty reliable. The most reliable model year of the first generation is 1998, and it was in between two problematic 1997 and 1999 model years. Also, the 2000′ and 2001′ Boxsters didn’t have many electrical and transmission-related faults like the 2003 model.

2008 and 2009 Porsche Boxster

If you are looking for a second-generation Boxster, the 2008 and 2009 model years are pretty reliable without many IMS issues. These models were pretty clean with zero reported engine oil leaks and cooling issues, and they didn’t have transmission-related problems either.

Out of the two, the 2009 Boxster model seemed slightly better since it didn’t have any reported issues at all, and it had a 4.5 out of 5 stars on its reliability report.

Is the Porsche Boxster worth buying?

When the time comes to draw the line on Porsche Boxster’s reliability, it’s clear that the car is a full-fledged Porsche with a bit more affordable price than the 911. It offers its features to drivers and while it’s not as capable as the 911 performance-wise, it’s still a great sports car.

It is a compact two-door ride, but that shouldn’t prevent interested drivers from buying one. It’s not a “poor man’s Porsche” as some people describe it, but rather an affordable entry into the Porsche lineup that shares the genuine Porsche vibe with the 911. In terms of reliability, there are only a few model years to go around, and we hope that our guide will help you with that.

If you’re dreaming about a sports car make sure to check out our guides on Porsche Cayman years to avoid, Porsche 997 years to avoid, or a classic Corvette C3 years to avoid, we’ve got all info on the good years and the not-so-good ones.