Best and worst Land Rover LR3 years — which to avoid

Thanks to the stellar success of the Range Rover model, Land Rover SUVs are these days as popular as ever. However, there were notable models even before the release of a modern Range Rover, and the LR3 Discovery was one of those. Still, we’ve had a fair share of complaints about the LR3 years to avoid, so our team just had to dig a bit deeper.

We made sure to cover all the aspects of the LR3’s reliability, from first-hand driver reports and reviews, to official records on complaints and recalls submitted to NHTSA, so we’ll walk you through our findings.

Why you can trust REREV’s advice on which car model years to avoid: Our car experts look at official data, ask real drivers what they think, and talk to experienced mechanics to make sure our list is useful. This reliable info can make buying a car easier for you. Want to know how we do it? Find out more about our research methodology.

How we rated the best and worst Land Rover LR3 years

As a driver, you need completely accurate information about the best and worst Land Rover LR3 years, and that’s why our team wanted to give you all the details according to official NHTSA complaints and problem reports. We also checked for recall logs to understand which problems persisted with the model for long enough to make it a bad choice.

Of course, we also wanted to give you the other side of the story which we accomplished to do by going over real-life driver reviews and ratings of the model according to their experiences with it. So, we were able to cross-reference all these pieces of information, and here’s a table of the best and worst years that we came up with:

Most common Land Rover LR3 problems

The Land Rover LR3 started production in 2005 and it lasted up to 2009 without many complaints about excessive wear of crucial components like the engine or the transmission. The V8 engine that came as standard for the US market proved to be as sturdy as a V8 gets, but drivers have reported a few other model-related concerns that were specific to this model.

1. Airbag-related problems

The worst problem that you could have in an LR3 Discovery regarding driving safety is a malfunctioning airbag module. It’s not so uncommon and drivers often visit the dealership to check why is the airbag light on in their cars.

We tried to get to the bottom of it and it seems that the problem was caused by a fractured airbag wire. This affected the operation of the airbag module and it was mostly down to the severity of the issue as to whether the airbags deployed or not in case of emergency.

2. Transmission lever issue

While the LR3 didn’t have any problems with the transmission itself, there’s a reported problem with the ignition switch and the transmission lever. This made it possible to remove the key from the ignition even if the transmission lever hadn’t been moved to the park mode previously.

Because of this, the driver may think that the vehicle is secured in park mode, while it turned out that a lot of cars would simply roll away. Not only would this cause damage to your car, but also to other cars by rolling down onto the street. Since it’s a serious issue, Land Rover issued an official recall in 2006 and the problem for the affected 2005 and 2006 models was solved during the software update of the ECU.

3. Air suspension height issues

As mentioned, the LR3 was equipped with air suspension and this was a technology reserved for luxury limousines of the time such as the Mercedes-Benz S-Class. However, while this update made the drive feel like the wheels were rolling down the cloud, things got worse when the time came to do some repairs.

Due to the age of the LR3 vehicles, the air suspension would fail sooner or later, and that’s a risk you’ll have to take by buying one. There’s a bit of a twist to the good side here as well – the issue was sometimes caused by a faulty suspension height sensor, so that made an easier fix. However, the price of repairing the entire air suspension system goes between $1800 and $2500, which is a big deal considering the current market price of the car.

4. Gasoline smell within the cabin

One of the worst things that could happen while you are driving is feeling a fuel smell within the cabin. Not only is it bothersome and bad for your health, but it may also take your focus off the road if you try to figure out why the fuel smell appears in the cabin.

The problem was in factory-installed fuel tanks that had a breather pipe in which fuel entered in case of fuel level higher than the detached pipe. Naturally, it causes fuel smell and improper fuel pressure which leads to misfires, lower engine performance, or rough idling. To make things worse, the leaking fuel could sometimes be seen below the car and these leaks caused a fire risk.

Worst Land Rover LR3 years to avoid

Well, now we come to the big question of which model years of the Land Rover Discovery LR3 to avoid due to the listed issues. The truth is – that this car is often considered unreliable by drivers who only view it through expensive repairs like air suspension fixing or the matter of dealing with the airbags.

However, these cars received far fewer complaints than some competitor models, so what are the worst Land Rover LR3 years? The worst Land Rover LR3 year is 2005 and it’s the only model year that had any reported issues that would cause you to steer away from it.

Second-generation Land Rover Discovery LR3 (2005 model year)

The first generation of the LR3 is the second generation of the Discovery as a model, so that’s why we’ll refer to it based on the famous Discovery nameplate. When you look at it that way, it’s clear that this generation of the Discovery is as sturdy as the other two, except for a 2005 model.

The 2005 LR3 had a few reported issues that made it the “worst” LR3 model, even though it didn’t receive a worrying amount of complaints. These were usually minor reported issues such as electrical issues, paint peeling, or drivetrain issues that were few, but still there.

However, there are some serious issues like fuel delivery system leaks and suspension problems. There was also a recall that dealt with the steering column issues for the 2005 and some 2006 models, so that’s another thing to keep in mind before the purchase.

There were a few reports of transmission failures, but these were so rare that we don’t think you should place them high on the list of things to keep in mind. It’s just worth knowing that if everything else seems fine, you may want to have a trusted mechanic check the shifting precision and hydraulic pressure of the automatic transmission.

What are the best Land Rover LR3 years to buy?

Knowing about the one LR3 model year to avoid also makes things a lot easier when it comes to the best model years. Naturally, all the other model years are pretty much safe to buy since there were only five production models offered on the US market. So, here’s a list of the best LR3 models you can buy on the used car market:

• 2006
• 2007
• 2008
• 2009

We’ll also take a closer look at the best-rated model to explain why it makes a reasonable purchase option, and in this case, it’s the 2009 model.

2009 Land Rover LR3

Out of all these, we recommend the 2009 LR3 model due to its reliability ratings and the fact that facelift models often get a lot of previous issues sorted. It certainly seems that way with the LR3, and you won’t make a mistake by going for any of the other models except for the 2005 one either.

You simply have to consider the costs of owning a premium-level off-road capable SUV that gets a bit old and outdated these days. We recommend you check the components that could lead to expensive repairs such as air suspension, transmission, and the fuel delivery system before making the purchase.

Is Land Rover LR3 worth buying?

Making a final verdict on the value of a used LR3 isn’t as easy as it seems. You simply have to consider all the maintenance costs which are frankly in the higher range for this type of car. You can expect to pay an average of around $1000, which is quite a sum considering the current value of the car.

Still, we have to say that it’s a reliable car as long as you avoid the 2005 model. The 4.4-liter V8 engine is a reliable option for US drivers and it’s only necessary to inspect the fuel delivery system, transmission, and air suspension before making the final call.

Considering the Jeep Wrangler, Toyota FJ Cruiser, or Jeep TJ for your next off-road adventure? Our overviews help you navigate the best and worst years for each, ensuring you make an informed decision by pointing out the peak and low model years for these rugged vehicles.